'The best books, reviewed with insight and charm, but without compromise.' - author Jackie French

Monday, 24 February 2014

Review: I Was Only Nineteen

Can a song become a children’s picture book?

John Schumann, songwriter, poet, singer and musician wrote about the Vietnam War in his song I Was Only 19.  The incredibly talented Craig Smith has translated John Schumann’s marvellous and moving lyrics into a visual feast for children aged 8+, and adults that adore picture books (like me!).

The answer is yes, a song can become a children’s picture book and much more. It can be a teaching tool, an historical document, an acknowledgement of sacrifice, evidence of loyalty and camaraderie, and the list goes on.

Craig Smith’s illustrations of watercolour and black and white bring visual life to the lyrics as the pictures tell their own story: the leaving, the warring, and the desolation of being separated from loved ones. The pictures speak about men that left as one person and came back someone entirely different. 

A grandfather remembers his soldier life and retells it to his grandson. He talks about the suffering and the mateship. He recalls the fear and pain, and the loss of friends that has stayed with him always. I was part of all those scenes; I felt, and heard, and cried with soldiers, mothers and families.

Craig Smith has gone to the heart of every word and has given us a valuable gift to keep along with the iconic lyrics that John Schuman became famous for. I was deeply moved by this book as will be all those open to something different in picture books.

There are teachers' notes available for this title.

Title: I was Only Nineteen
Author: John Schumann
Illustrator: Craig Smith
Publisher: Allen & Unwin, $24.99 RRP
Publication Date: 26 February 2014
Format: Hardcover
ISBN: 9781743317235
For ages: 8+
Type: Picture Book

1 comment:

  1. An excellent review of I Was Only Nineteen. The Redgum song cuts deep unto so many lives. This book is definitely going on my TBR wishlist.


We value your comments, however, please note that all comments are moderated and need to be approved before publication, so spammers ... don't waste your time. Your comments will never be published.